Acta Palaeontol. Pol. 64 (X): xxx–xxx, 2019 https://doi.org/10.4202/app.00544.2018 A new capybara from the late Miocene of San Juan Province, Argentina, and its phylogenetic implications ESPERANZA CERDEÑO, MARÍA E. PÉREZ, CECILIA M. DESCHAMPS, and VÍCTOR H. CONTRERAS Cerdeño, E., Pérez, M.E., Deschamps, C.M., and Contreras, V.H. 2019. A new capybara from the late Miocene of San Juan Province, Argentina, and its phylogenetic implications. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 64 (x): xxx–xxx. A new hydrochoerine rodent, Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. (Caviidae), is described based on the specimen INGEO-PV 87. It was recovered from the late Miocene Las Flores Formation, cropping out at the Puchuzum locality, San Juan Province, Argentina. The new species is based on a particular combination of characters, among which the following can be highlighted: p4 with internal fissures equally deep as in Cardiatherium paranense, secondary external fissure as in Cardiatherium patagonicum, and lacking the fifth internal fissure and supernumerary internal fissure, as in C. paranense; m3 with a conspicuous labial column in the posterior ramus of the second prism; very deep primary and secondary external fissures in upper cheek teeth, the former producing a labial strong step-shaped profile in M2; sagittal crest on the parietals; bullae small in ventral view; scars of the origin of the masseter medialis muscle with an anterior projection up to the level of the incisive foramen and the maxilla-premaxilla suture. The phylogenetic analysis supports the taxonomic proposal of creating a new species of Cardiatherium and shows C. calingastaense sp. nov. as the sister group of the other species of the genus. The lineage leading to the clade Cardiatherium + largest capybaras would have originated at least during the Chasicoan SALMA (early late Miocene). Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. adds to the previous record of Cardiatherium chasicoense and Cardiatherium paranense in the late Miocene of San Juan and Mendoza provinces, respectively, thus increasing the diversity of capybaras in central-west Argentina. Key words: Mammalia, Rodentia, Caviidae, Cardiatherium, systematics, phylogeny, late Miocene, Argentina. Esperanza Cerdeño [espe@mendoza-conicet.gob-ar], Instituto Argentino de Nivología, Glaciología y Ciencias Ambi- entales (IANIGLA), Centro Científico Tecnológico, CONICET Mendoza, Av. Ruiz Leal s/n, 5500, Mendoza, Argentina. María E. Pérez [mperez@mef.org.ar], Museo Paleontológico Egidio Feruglio, Av. Fontana 140, U9100GYO, Trelew, Argentina. Cecilia M. Deschamps [ceci@fcnym.unlp.edu.ar], Comisión de Investigaciones Científicas de la provincia de Buenos Aires, Argentina; División Paleontología Vertebrados, Unidades de Investigación Anexo Museo de La Plata, Facultad de Ciencias Naturales y Museo, Universidad Nacional de La Plata, 122 y 60, 1900, La Plata, Argentina. Víctor H. Contreras [vcontre@unsj-cuim.edu.ar], Instituto de Geología Dr. Emiliano P. Aparicio (INGEO) y Depar- tamento Geología, FCEFN, Universidad Nacional de San Juan, Ignacio de la Roza y Meglioli, 5400 Rivadavia, San Juan, Argentina. Received 5 September 2018, accepted 19 October 2018, available online 26 November 2018. Copyright © 2018 E. Cerdeño et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (for details please see http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Introduction The Neogene continental outcrops in the San Juan Province, central-west Argentina (Fig. 1), encompass two localities that have yielded important late Miocene vertebrate remains. These localities are Puchuzum (Calingasta Valley), whose faunal assemblage is assigned to the Huayquerian SALMA (late Tortonian–Messinian; see Deschamps et al. 2013, for further details in bio- and chronostratigraphic equivalences), and Loma de Las Tapias, where two different levels are recognized as corresponding to the Chasicoan (Tortonian) and the Huayquerian South American Land Mammal Ages (SALMAs; Contreras et al. 1995; Peralta et al. 1995; Contreras 1996; Cerdeño and Contreras 2000; Ciancio et al. 2006; León and Bracco 2008; Bracco et al. 2011; Contreras and Baraldo 2011; Suvires and Contreras 2011). Concerning the fossils from Puchuzum, different lev- els of the section (distinct architectural elements) have provided remains of molluscs, ostracods, insects, fishes, and palynomorphs (found within lacustrine sediments), on the one hand, and mammals and birds (derived from flood plain sediments), together with footprint tracks, on 2 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 64 (X), 2019 the other hand (Contreras 1996; Contreras and Peralta 1998; Prámparo et al. 1998; Contreras and Cerdeño 2010; Bracco et al. 2011). Among mammal remains, only the specimens of a Hegetotheriidae (Notoungulata) were studied in de- tail (Cerdeño and Contreras 2000). However, the faunal assemblage also includes xenarthrans, litopterns and ro- dents (Contreras and Cerdeño 2010; Bracco et al. 2011). The hegetotheriid Hemihegetotherium achataleptum indi- cated a Huayquerian SALMA for this fauna (Cerdeño and Contreras 2000), but no absolute age has been obtained for the unit. Herein we present the study of a well-preserved skull and mandible of a capybara, associated with some fragments of postcranial bones. Capybaras are the largest living rodents, represented by the single genus Hydrochoerus, reaching a body length of 100–130 cm, and adult males weighting up to 91 kg (Mones and Ojasti 1986). They have semiaquatic habits, and live in groups usually ranging in size from two to 30 individ- uals (Dunnum 2015). They have characteristic euhypsod- ont, multilaminated cheek teeth (Novak 1991; Deschamps et al. 2007). The phylogenetic relationships of capybaras with other cavioid rodents and the status of hydrochoerids have been revised during the last years (Rowe and Honeycutt 2002; Vucetich and Pérez 2011; Upham and Patterson 2015; Pérez et al. 2018, and references therein). After these au- thors, capybaras would be within the Family Caviidae as a subfamily, Hydrochoerinae, together with the extinct car- diomyines and the small Kerodon (rock-dwelling mocos), the other living genus of the subfamily (Rowe and Honeycutt 2002; Pérez and Pol 2012; Pérez et al. 2018). The fossil record of capybaras (that is, hydrochoerines excluding ‘cardiomyines’) goes back to the late Miocene, and many taxa were described since the 19th century (Ameghino 1883a, b; Rovereto 1914; Kraglievich 1930; Rusconi 1933, 1935, 1944; Pascual and Bondesio 1963; Francis and Mones 1965a, b; Bondesio 1985a, b; Mones 1991; among others), but revisions such as those by Mones (1984) and, more recently, Vucetich et al. (2005, 2012, 2014a, b, 2015) and Deschamps et al. (2007, 2009) have evidenced a great taxo- nomic overestimation due to ontogenetic variation that had not been previously evaluated; consequently, these authors drastically reduced the known diversity of hydrochoerines, especially for the late Miocene–Pliocene interval. Within the late Miocene, the oldest species is Cardia- therium chasicoense Pascual and Bondesio, 1968 from the Chasicoan SALMA, which is known from the type locality Arroyo Chasicó (Buenos Aires Province) as well as from the lower levels of the Loma de Las Tapias Formation in San Juan Province (Contreras 2000; Contreras et al. 2001; Deschamps et al. 2007, 2009; Contreras and Baraldo 2011). In turn, the Huayquerian SALMA localities with hydro- choerines are more abundant and the material was re-eval- uated by Vucetich et al. (2005). These authors described Cardiatherium patagonicum as the southernmost record, from the Puerto Madryn Formation (Chubut Province). At the same time, they proposed that all material from the Ituzaingó Formation (Entre Ríos Province, north- east Argentina) would correspond to only one species, C. paranense, which was later confirmed by Vucetich et al. (2014b). These authors also recognized C. paranense in Tupungato, Mendoza Province (central-west Argentina), from levels of the Río de Los Pozos Formation, referred to the late Miocene (Yrigoyen 1993). Another species assigned to this genus, Cardiatherium orientalis Francis and Mones, 1965b, was recorded in the late Miocene of Uruguay, and tentatively recognized later in the Cerro Azul Formation, La Fig. 1. Geographical map showing position of studied area within San Juan Province, central-west Argentina (A) and location of outcrops of the Las Flores Formation (striped area) near the village of Puchuzum (B). The asterisk indicates the fossil locality. 500 km W 69 33’ C a s ta o v ie jo R iv e r N S 31 06’36’’ 1 km C a n d e la ria C re e k PuchuzumPuchuzum 80 70 60 55 45 35 25 BA CERDEÑO ET AL.—A NEW MIOCENE CAPYBARA FROM ARGENTINA 3 Pampa Province, Argentina, as C. aff. orientalis (Vucetich et al. 2014b). The genus Cardiatherium is also known in the late Miocene of Brazil, Peru and Venezuela (Deschamps et al. 2013 and literature therein). The present contribution focuses on the description of a new species of Cardiatherium based on well-preserved cranial remains, previously mentioned as Cardiatherium sp. (Contreras and Cerdeño 2010), found in the province of San Juan. On the basis of a cladistic analysis, the phylogenetic position of the new species and the monophyly of the genus Cardiatherium within Caviidae were tested. Institutional abbreviations.—GHUNLPam, Cátedra de Geología Histórica, Universidad Nacional de La Pampa, Santa Rosa, Argentina; INGEO-PV, Vertebrate Palae onto- logical collection, Instituto de Geología Dr. Emiliano P. Aparicio, Universidad Nacional de San Juan, San Juan, Argentina; MACN, Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales, “B. Rivadavia”, Buenos Aires, Argentina; MLP, Museo de La Plata, Argentina; MMH-CH, Museo Municipal de Cien cias Naturales de Monte Hermoso, Argentina; MMP, Museo Municipal de Ciencias Naturales “Lorenzo Scaglia”, Mar del Plata, Argentina; MNHN-AYO, Ayo-Ayo collec- tion, Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, Paris, France; MPEF-PV, Palaeontological collection, Museo Pale on to- lógico “Egidio Feruglio”, Trelew, Argentina; PVSJ, Verte- brate Palaeontological collection, Instituto y Museo de Cien- cias Naturales, Universidad Nacional de San Juan, San Juan, Argentina; SPV-FHC, Sección Paleontología Verte brados, Departamento de Paleontología, Facultad de Humanidades y Ciencias, Montevideo, Uruguay. Other abbreviations.—ch., character; he, external fissure; HFI, fundamental internal fissure; hfe, fundamental external fissure; hi, internal fissure; HPE, primary external fissure; hpi, primary internal fissure; HSE/hse, secondary external fissure; hsi, secondary internal fissure; hsni, internal super- numerary fissure; hti, tertiary internal fissure; M/m, upper/ lower molar; P/p, upper/lower premolar; pr, prism; prIIa/b, anterior and posterior lobes of prII; prsa, anterior secondary prism; SALMA, South American Land Mammal Age. Material and methods The studied material, INGEO-PV 87, includes a single spec- imen composed of a well-preserved skull with associated mandible, and some fragmentary postcranial remains of the same individual, housed at the Vertebrate Palaeontological Collection of the INGEO. It was compared with the ho- lotypes and referred materials of Cardiatherium chasico- ense, C. paranense, C. orientalis, and C. rosendoi, housed in the following Argentinean museums: IMUSJ, MACN, MLP, MMH, MMP, and MPEF. The specimens of C. pata- gonicum used for comparisons and the phylogenetic analy- sis were taken from Vucetich et al. (2005) and Dozo et al. (2010). Cardiatherium aff. orientalis from the Cerro Azul Formation in La Pampa Province was also used in this study. The detailed list of revised remains is in Appendix 1. Dental nomenclature is given in Fig. 2A–E (flexus/flexid were originally named as fissures by Mones 1991, and are here indistinctly used) and follows partially Vucetich et al. (2005) and modifications according to Pérez et al. (2018). However, some modifications have been introduced in this paper, in order to fit with a new character observed in the p4 of Cardiatherium patagonicum and the new species here described. This new feature is the external flexid of the pos- terior lobe of prII of p4 (Fig. 2A), here referred to as hse or h2e according to the nomenclature of m1–m3 (h.s.e. sensu Mones 1991; Fig. 2B–D). Hence, the external fissure of the anterior supernumerary prism of p4 (prsa) is named here h3e (h.s.e. or h.2e sensu Mones 1991; Fig. 2A, D). Lobes of caviids are referred to as prisms in hydrochoerines. Cranial nomenclature follows Vucetich et al. (2014b) and Pérez et al. (2018). Skull measurements follow Vucetich et al. (2014b): (i) posterior width of the incisive foramen; (ii) rostral width at the anterior margin of the anterior root of the zygomatic arch (complete or up to the midline in incomplete specimens); (iii) width between the anteriormost points of the scars marking the origin of the masseter medialis muscle; (iv) rostral width at the level of P4, measured at the alveolar margin of prism I; (v) rostral width at the posterior margin of the anterior root of the zygomatic arch (complete or up to the midline A B C D E 5 mm Fig. 2. Dental nomenclature (occlusal view). A–C, E. Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. A. Right p4. B. Right m1. C. Right m3. E. Right M1. D. Cardiatherium patagonicum, right p4. Abbreviations: c, column; he, external fissure (or flexid); HFI, fundamental internal fissure (hypoflexus); hfe, fundamental external fissure; hi, internal fissure; HPE, primary external fissure; hpi, primary internal fissure; HSE/hse, secondary external fissure; hsi, secondary internal fissure; hsni, internal supernumerary fissure; hti, tertiary internal fissure; pr, prism; prIIa/b, anterior and posterior lobes of pr II; prsa, anterior secondary prism. 4 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 64 (X), 2019 in incomplete specimens); (vi) rostral width at the level of M2, measured at the alveolar margin of prII; (vii) distance between the posterior margin of the incisive foramen and P4; (viii) P4–M1 anteroposterior length; and (ix) angle of the beginning of the ventral anterior zygomatic arch and the alveolar series, in lateral view. In order to explore the phy- logenetic relationships of the taxon studied, we scored the new anatomical information throughout the last version of the combined Cavioidea matrix (Madozzo Jaén et al. 2018), originally published by Pérez and Pol (2012). The combined dataset of morphological and molecular characters (SOM 1 and 2; Supplementary Online Material available at http://app. pan.pl/SOM/app64-Cerdeno_etal_SOM.pdf) was modified. Some multistate characters are ordered, nine characters have been modified and eight characters are new (see SOM 2). The new dataset was analysed under equally weighted par- simony in TNT (Goloboff and Catalano 2015), using a heu- ristic search of 1000 replicates of Wagner trees, followed by tree bisection and reconnection branch swapping. Node supports were calculated using absolute GC bootstrap fre- quencies calculated after 1000 pseudoreplicates. The modi- fied Stratigraphic Manhattan Measure (Pol and Norell 2001) was used to calibrate the most parsimonious phylogenetic trees and the chronostratigraphic information for fossil taxa using TNT. Geological setting The specimen herein studied was collected in 2006 in levels of the Las Flores Formation, in the area of Puchuzum in the Calingasta Valley (Fig. 1). This unit is widely developed both geographically and in thickness in the Iglesia valley, where its type locality has been recognized (Wetten 1975; Contreras et al. 2013 and references therein). The strati- graphic section at Puchuzum was previously described by Peralta et al. (1995) (see also Bracco et al. 2011), and corre- sponds to the Neogene sediments cropping out at both mar- gins of the Candelaria Creek, in the piedmont of the Manrique Mountains, Cordillera Frontal. According to geological and palaeontological studies at Puchuzum (Peralta et al. 1995; Contreras et al. 1995; Contreras 1996; Contreras and Peralta 1998; Cerdeño and Contreras 2000; Bracco et al. 2011; Bogan et al. 2018), the bony remains recorded in this locality, which come from the middle of the exposed section, were assigned to the latest Miocene. This mid-section is characterized by brown-reddish to greyish psammo-pelitic deposits, reddish silty to silty-sandy beds, with some carbonaceous and con- glomeratic levels, and with cut and fill structures. Three man- tiform interbeddings of bentonitic clay, 3 to 10 m thick, are distinguished by their yellowish coloration. These bentonitic packages clearly correspond to sedimentary events that orig- inated in lakes, evidenced by the recorded fossils: bivalves, gastropods, insects, and fish (Peralta et al. 1995; Contreras 1996; Contreras and Peralta 1998; Bracco et al. 2011; Bogan et al. 2018). In turn, the mammals from this mid-section at Puchuzum represent a Huayquerian faunal association within the late Miocene (Peralta et al. 1995; Contreras 1996; Cerdeño and Contreras 2000). The general palaeoenvironment of the mid-section of Puchuzum is interpreted as a fluvial system with great devel- opment of flood plains and rivers, more or less channelled and strongly sinuous. The lacustrine interbeddings correspond to increasing and decreasing events of the lacustrine basin, in- fluenced by tectonic and hydrologic activity. A similar situa- tion has been interpreted for the Las Flores Formation in the Iglesia Basin (Milana 1994; Jordan et al. 1997). Systematic palaeontology Rodentia Bowdich, 1821 Hystricognathi Tullberg, 1899 Cavioidea (Fischer, 1817) sensu Kraglievich 1930 Caviidae (Fischer, 1817) sensu Waterhouse 1839 Hydrochoerinae (Gray, 1825) Gill, 1872 Genus Cardiatherium Ameghino, 1883b Type species: Cardiatherium doeringi Ameghino, 1883b (= Cardiathe- rium paranense [Ameghino, 1883a] in Vucetich et al. 2014b); Paraná River cliffs, Entre Ríos, Argentina, Ituzaingó Formation, Late Miocene. Species included: Cardiatherium patagonicum Vucetich, Deschamps, Olivares, and Dozo, 2005, Cardiatherium orientalis (Francis and Mo- nes, 1965b), Cardiatherium chasicoense (Pascual and Bondesio, 1968), Cardiatherium rosendoi Bondesio, 1985b, Cardiatherium talicei Fran- cis and Mones, 1965a, and Cardiatherium isseli Rovereto, 1914. Stratigraphic and geographic range.—Late Miocene (Chasi- coan and Huayquerian SALMAs) of Argentina, Brazil, Peru, Uruguay, and Venezuela. Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. Figs. 3, 4. 2010 Cardiatherium sp.; Contreras and Cerdeño 2010: 8R. Etymology: After the Calingasta Valley, where the locality of Puchu- zum is located. Holotype: INGEO-PV 87, skull and mandible of an adult individual, together with associated fragments of vertebrae and long bones. Type locality: Right side of the Candelaria Creek, Puchuzum area, Cal- ingasta Valley, San Juan Province, central-west Argentina. Type horizon: Mid stratigraphic section of Las Flores Formation, late Miocene. Diagnosis.—Cavioid diagnosed by the following unique combination of characters (autapomorphies marked with an asterisk): euhypsodont cheek teeth; p4 with three prisms and P4 with two-lobed prisms as in other Hydrochoerinae; p4 with hfe, h3e, hpi, h2i, and h3i as in Hydrochoeropsis, Phugatherium, Neochoerus, and Hydrochoerus; h2i and h3i equally deep as in Cardiatherium paranense, Hydro- choero psis dasseni, but differing from Hydrochoerus and Neochoerus in which h2i is shallower than h3i and its apex is behind the hfe; p4 with hse (h2e) as in C. patagonicum; CERDEÑO ET AL.—A NEW MIOCENE CAPYBARA FROM ARGENTINA 5 Fig. 3. Holotype (INGEO-PV 87) of the hydrochoerine rodent Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov., late Miocene, Puchuzum, San Juan Province, Argentina. A. Skull in dorsal (A1) and ventral (A2) views, and detail of the scars for masseter medialis muscle (A3); correspondence indicated by lines. B. Mandible in occlusal (B1) and left lateral (B2) views. nasals dorsal projection of premaxilla frontals temporal fossae sagittal crest suture suture anterior root of the zygomatic arch jugal squamosal incisive foramen palatal foramen mesopterygoid fossa tympanic bulla mental foramen bottom of incisor alveolus B1 2B A1 2A 3A 3 mm 30 mm 30 mm 6 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 64 (X), 2019 p4 lacks h5i and hsni, as in C. paranense; hpi, hti, HFI, and hfe of m1/M1–m2/M2 not splitting the teeth, as in other Cardiatherium and differing from Hydrochoeropsis, Phuga- therium, Neochoerus, and Hydrochoerus, in which those flexi/ids completely cross the tooth; *m3 with a conspicuous labial column in the posterior ramus of prIIa in contrast to other species; HPE and HSE very deep, the latter shorter than the former but deeper than in other species and oriented backwards; M3 with nine prisms; sagittal crest on the pari- etals, unlike Hydrochoeropsis, Phugatherium, Neochoerus, and Hydrochoerus, in which the area between both temporal fossae is plane, without forming the sagittal crest; bullae small in ventral view as in Neochoerus and Hydrochoerus; *scars marking the origin of the masseter medialis muscle on the beginning of the anterior zygomatic arch (ventral face), with an anterior projection up to the level of the incisive fora- men and the maxilla-premaxilla suture. Description.—As it is reflected in the diagnosis of the new proposed taxon, the specimen INGEO-PV 87 (Figs. 3, 4) may be referred to the genus Cardiatherium, discard- ing its assignment to other genera of capybaras such as Phugatherium, Hydrochoeropsis or the modern lineages represented by Hydrochoerus and Neochoerus (see also Phylogenetic analysis and Discussion). Therefore, the fol- lowing description is focused on the comparison of the stud- ied material with the known species of Cardiatherium. Skull: It is somewhat mediolaterally deformed and lacks the left zygomatic arch, the left parietal-occipital area, and the left M3 (Fig. 3A1, A2). In dorsal view (Fig. 3A1), the nasal is anterolaterally broken but the preserved portion indicates that this bone is long. The nasal is a little longer than the frontal in the new species as in C. paranense and the biggest capybaras (Phugatherium, Hydrochoeropsis, Hydrochoerus). Laterally, the nasal is in contact with the dorsal projection of the pre- maxilla and posteriorly with the frontal. The nasal is dorsally slightly convex, differing from the strongly bulging condi- tion of C. paranense and from Hydrochoerus, in which the nasal is slightly bulky in the middle portion. The posterior border of the nasal is anteriorly slightly concave, differing from the strongly concave border of C. paranense. The nasal and frontal (Fig. 3A1) are proportionately narrower than in C. paranense, Phugatherium, and Hydrochoerus. The frontal and the anterior portion of the parietal are dorsally flat as in most Hydrochoerinae. The posterior portion of the parietal has a temporal fossa posterolaterally concave and the tempo- ral lines join, although not completely fusing, in a short sag- ittal crest that diverges again posteriorly at the nuchal crest. This condition contrasts with that of the largest capybaras, which present an interposed area between the temporal fos- sae (which are shallower than in C. calingastaense sp. nov.) instead of the sagittal crest. The postorbital apophyses are incomplete and would have been short. In right lateral view, the ventral portion of the zygo- matic arch is preserved and is similar to the condition of Hydrochoerus. The maxillary anterior root of the arch is dorso-ventrally flattened and narrows posteriorly, be- ing dorso-ventrally elongated like the jugal, which is an- tero-posteriorly short. The squamosal forms the posterior portion of the arch and is posteriorly extended above the tympanic bulla. The external auditory meatus is above the level of the molar series. The angle formed by the anterior root of the zygomatic arch and the alveolar plane in Lateral view is <20°, similar to C. paranense, but different from C. aff. orientalis from the Cerro Azul Formation, in which it is 24–26° (Vucetich et al. 2014b). In ventral view (Fig. 3A2), the diastema is longer than the molariform series (Table 1), like in C. paranense, C. patagonicum, H. dasseni, and P. novum. The scars for the insertion of the masseter superficialis muscle are anteriorly convergent as in the other species of Cardiatherium; how- ever, in INGEO-PV 87 there is an additional scar in this area. One is oval, transversely concave, placed between the root of the zygomatic arch and the P4, but extended anteriorly Table 1. Comparison of skull dimensions (in mm, except for 9, 12) of Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. following Vucetich et al. (2014b) with other late Miocene Cardiatherium and Recent Hydrochoerus hydrochaeris. Abbreviations: 1, posterior width of the incisive foramen; 2, rostral width at the anterior margin of the anterior root of the zygomatic arch (complete or up to the midline in incomplete specimens); 3, width between the anteriormost points of the scars marking the origin of the masseter medialis muscle; 4, rostral width at the level of P4, measured at the alveolar margin of prism I; 5, rostral width at the posterior margin of the anterior root of the zygomatic arch (complete or up to the midline in incomplete specimens); 6, rostral width at the level of M2, measured at the alveolar margin of prII; 7, distance between the posterior margin of the incisive foramen and P4; 8, P4–M1 anteroposterior length; 9, angle of the beginning of the ventral anterior zygomatic arch and the alveolar series, in lateral view; 10, length of upper diastema; 11, length of P4–M3; 12, relationship (%) between dimensions 10 and 11; 1 holotype of C. paranense and MLP 71-VI-16-1; 2 GHUNLPam 27389 (the smallest) and GHUNLPam 5274 (the largest). Skull dimension 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. (INGEO-PV 87) 5.8 29.0 13.5/21.8 18.1/25.1 29.9 32.6 19.0 19.3 18 71.1 56.6 75.3 Cardiatherium paranense (N = 12) minimum 3.2 22.6 –/16.0 10.7/– 21.4 24.0 9.0 12.5 18 132.0 131.0 196.8 maximum 8.0 32.4 –/28.0 19.4/– 37.7 43.9 22.5 22.5 19 175.0 159.0 178.6 Cardiatherium aff. orientalis (N = 5) minimum 2.5 21.8 –/16.0 12.9/– 22.1 30.5 15.1 10.2 24 244.2 241.5 293.8 maximum 3.0 29.0 –/27.0 17.4/– 28.2 36.8 18.8 18.8 26 258.0 253.0 291.3 Cardiatherium patagonicum (MPEF-PV 2521) – – – – – – – – – 75.0 57.0 76 Hydrochoerus hydrochaeris (N = 8) minimum 5.0 16.2 26.2 11.0 20.2 23.6 9.2 11.6 13 25.1 37.2 148.2 maximum 10.2 40.0 34.1 24.6 43.2 52.0 24.2 27.2 17 67.9 79.3 116.8 CERDEÑO ET AL.—A NEW MIOCENE CAPYBARA FROM ARGENTINA 7 beyond this tooth, as observed in the other species of the genus; and the other one is another smooth surface at an ob- tuse angle with the first scar, which is directed to the sagittal plane, reaching the border of the incisive foramen, where the premaxilla-maxilla suture is located (Fig. 3A2, A3). The inci- sive foramen is ovoid and broad as in C. paranense whereas it is narrow in C. aff. orientalis (Table 1). The base of P4 does not project laterally and therefore does not form the bulge ob- servable in ventral view in C. paranense. The ratio between the distance from the base of the incisive foramen up to the middle point between both P4s and the upper tooth series length is close to the minimum values of Cardiatherium, but different from the large capybaras (Phugatherium) and the modern lineages (Hydrochoerus–Neochoerus), in which the tooth series is proportionally longer (Table 1). The palate is rather shallow; from the level of M1 to that of the third prism of M3, there is a medium, narrow crest with a long and narrow palatal foramen at each side (M2–M3 level). The mesopterygoid fossa is narrow in outline, with a rounded anterior margin at the level of the posterior portion of the M3, as in C. paranense and C. pata gonicum. The tooth rows are divergent, but with a smooth curvature with M3 aligned with P4–M2, as in C. paranense. In C. patagonicum and C. aff. orientalis, the M3 are nearly parallel. The basicranium is badly preserved, although part of the basisphenoid and the right tympanic bulla are preserved. The bulla is relatively small. The occipital face is incomplete and displaced; the right paraoccipital apophysis is distally incomplete, but it would have been relatively long (Fig. 3A1). Mandible: The mandible preserves the symphysis, with the incisors, most of the left horizontal ramus, with p4–m3, and the anterior part of the right ramus (Fig. 3B). The right cheek teeth were recovered separately, but complete. The symphysis is narrow and procumbent, with a smooth me- dian keel on the labial side; the posterior end of the symphy- sis does not reach the premolar level. The horizontal rami are well divergent; they are wide and vertically convex; ventrally, the area from the level below m1 to the base of the symphysis is flattened. The mental foramen is located anteriorly to p4 and at the dorso-ventral midpoint of the lateral surface of the dentary. The bottom of the i1 alveolus reaches internally the anterior half of the m2 and widens the lingual side of the ramus (clearly visible on the left side). The posterior border of the symphysis in C. calingastaense sp. nov. is below p4; according to Vucetich et al. (2005) and Deschamps et al. (2007), its position depends on the age of individuals, located anterior of p4 in juveniles and below the midpoint of p4 in larger (older) individuals. Main mandibu- lar measurements are provided in Table 2. Dentition: Both upper and lower incisors are narrow (I1, 8.1 mm; i1, 7.4 mm and 7.6 mm) and strongly curved, Fig. 4. Occlusal dental details of the holotype (INGEO-PV 87) of the hydrochoerine rodent Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov., late Miocene, Puchuzum, San Juan Province, Argentina. A. Right P4–M3. B. Left P4–M1. C. Left M1–M2. D. Posterior part of right M3. E. Left p4–m3. F. Right m1. G. Left m3. H. Left p4. I. Right p4. Table 2. Mandibular dimensions (in mm) of Cardiatherium calin- gastaense sp. nov. (INGEO-PV 87). Symphysis length 51.5 Anterior transversal diameter of symphysis 23.6 Transversal diameter symphysis at foramen level 31.9 Anterior height of symphysis c. 23.4 Height symphysis at foramen level 24.0 Transversal diameter between p4s, anterior to alveolus 30.6 Height horizontal ramus ahead left p4 20.3 Maximum width anterior to lateral crest 67.1 B C D F G H I A E 10 mm 5 mm 8 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 64 (X), 2019 with bevelled occlusal surface and enamel only on the la- bial side (Fig. 3B). Among upper cheek teeth (Fig. 4A–D; Table 3), P4, M1, and M2 are formed by two heart-shaped prisms, joined by a short isthmus. As in all species of Cardiatherium, HPE is deeper than HSE, unlike Phugatherium in which these flexi are almost similar in depth (Fig. 5A–E). In INGEO-PV 87, the HPE is very deep and curved backward, in such a way that in M2 it reaches the labial side and produces a defor- mation of this wall resulting in a strong step-shaped profile (Figs. 4B, C, 5A). The HSE is shorter than HPE, but is deeper than in the other species and oriented slightly back- ward (Fig. 5A–C); only the largest specimen of C. patagon- icum has an HSE similar in depth to C. calingastaense sp. nov., but anteriorly concave. P4 has undulated walls of HPE. The HFI is so deep that it almost splits prI from prII. M3 has nine prisms; prI is bilobed with a deep HPE similar to those of the other upper cheek teeth; the other eight prisms are laminar with a shallow, open V-shaped labial fissure in prII to prVII whereas in prVIII there is a barely marked labial concavity; as usual in capybaras, prIX is transversally shorter with a convex posterior margin and no labial fissure (Figs. 4D, 5A). Among lower cheek teeth (Figs. 4E–I, 6A; Table 4), p4 has a deep h3e, bifurcated at the end, and anteriorly directed. C. calingastaense sp. nov. lacks h4i and h5i as C. paranense (Fig. 6C), whereas h5i is extended up to 25% of the occlusal surface in C. patagonicum (Fig. 6B), C. orientalis (Fig. 6D) and C. chasicoense (Fig. 6E). C. calingastaense sp. nov. and C. aff. orientalis have no supernumerary internal flexid (hsni) typical of C. orientalis and C. patagonicum (Fig. 6B, D). The hfe is also deep, wide and transversely di- rected whereas in other species it is oblique. Lingually, the hpi is transversely directed and very deep, reaching almost the labial side, producing a deformation on this margin; at the same time, the third external flexid (h2e) is markedly concave (Figs. 4H, I, 6A) whereas in C. patagonicum (also with very deep hpi) the h2e is only incipient (Fig. 6B). The h2i and h3i are long and also bifurcated at the end, and both delimit a conspicuous internal column (c3). In C. pa- tagonicum, h2i is much shallower than h3i; in C. paranense (Fig. 6C) and C. chasicoense (Fig. 6E), these flexids are shallower and similar in depth, those of the latter being the shallowest. The m1–m2 are similar in morphology (Figs. 4F, 6A). The hsi penetrates less than 50% of the width of prI as in Table 3. Comparison of upper tooth dimensions (in mm) of Cardiatherium. a minimum and maximum values after Vucetich et al. (2014b); * M1 and M2 not differentiated; AW, anterior width, L, length; PW, posterior width; W, width; approximate values in parentheses. P4 M1 M2 M3 L AW PW L AW PW L AW PW L W Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. (INGEO-PV-87) right 10.0 6.3 7.6 8.8 (8.0) 8.5 8.5 7.7 7.9 28.5 11.0 left (9.5) (6.8) – 9.2 98.4 (8.4) (8.9) (7.4) (7.5) – – Cardiatherium chasicoensea* minimum 8.0 7.2 7.5 8.1 6.7 7.6 12.7 5.1 maximum 8.6 7.2 7.6 9.2 7.6 8.3 20.1 8.0 Cardiatherium paranensea minimum 6.0 4.6 4.6 5.1 4.9 4.6 4.9 5.4 5.4 9.2 5.9 maximum 12.0 8.2 9.7 11.0 8.7 9.7 9.1 6.4 7.2 37.5 10.7 Cardiatherium aff. orientalisa minimum 4.8 3.0 3.6 4.0 3.33 4.3 5.6 5.9 5.9 6.8 3.0 maximum 9.7 5.2 6.7 8.9 7.2 7.0 8.1 7.5 7.6 21.5 7.7 Cardiatherium patagonicuma* minimum 6.8 4.8 6.1 4.4 3.8 4.3 14.1 3.6 maximum 9.2 6.5 8.0 9.9 7.0 8.5 25.6 8.5 Table 4. Comparison of lower tooth dimensions (in mm) of Cardiatherium. a minimum and maximum values after Vucetich et al. (2005); b values correspond to the holotype MLP 40-XI-15-1; c values after Deschamps et al. (2009), a very small m1/2 of Cardiatherium patagonicum was not here considered; * m1–m2 not differentiated; AW, anterior width; L, length; MW, medium width; PW, posterior width; approximate values in parentheses. p4 m1 m2 m3 L AW MW PW L AW PW L AW PW L AW MW PW Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. (INGEO-PV-87) left 14.4 5.3 7.0 6.8 11.7 7.6 7.0 12.2 7.9 8.2 16.3 10.7 11.4 9.7 right 13.8 5.3 6.7 6.9 11.5 7.3 7.0 12.6 (8.1) 8.0 17.0 10.9 11.7 – Cardiatherium paranensea minimum 9.7 4.0 5.1 5.1 5.7 4.0 4.1 8.9 4.9 6.4 12.6 8.0 – – maximumb 19.8 6.4 7.8 8.8 15.8 9.6 10.1 17.6 9.6 11.6 21.7 10.4 – – Cardiatherium orientalis (holotype)a 11.2 4.6 5.2 5.9 9.6 5.6 6.1 0.3 6.0 7.0 13.4 7.0 – – Cardiatherium aff. orientalisa minimum 9.9 3.8 4.8 4.9 8.0 4.5 5.1 >8 5.3 >5 13.6 8.2 – – maximum 23.0 8.5 10.6 11.2 18.5 12.1 10.2 20.9 >11 12.4 15.2 9.1 – – Cardiatherium patagonicuma,* minimum 7.2 2.8 3.3 3.8 5.6 3.3 3.2 – 7.2 – – maximum 12.0 4.6 5.9 6.2 13.3 8.8 9.2 – 9.6 – – Cardiatherium chasicoense* minimumc 6.3 2.1 3.2 3.6 6.1 3.4 5.3 9.7 4.8 6.1 5.8 maximumc 13.7 4.8 6.8 7.3 11.5 7.6 7.6 15.5 7.6 8.6 9.4 CERDEÑO ET AL.—A NEW MIOCENE CAPYBARA FROM ARGENTINA 9 the other species of Cardiatherium, whereas hti is deep (crossing the prism but not splitting as in C. patagonicum; Fig. 6B) and Phugatherium) and bifurcated at the end, pro- ducing a deformation of the labial margin at this point. The hse is deep and wide. The m3 is the longest molar of the series, and flexids are not bifurcated. This molar has a conspicuous labial column in the posterior ramus of prIIa, delimited by two accessory fissures between hse and hfe (Figs. 4G, 6A). The previous comparative description has been focused on the best-known species, but some comparison can also be provided for two other poorly known taxa. In C. isseli (holo- type and only specimen MACN 6354; middle Miocene, Río Negro Province; Rovereto 1914), the p4 is quite similar, but the m3 differs because the anterior margin of prI is straight and the hsi is very deep. In C. talicei (holotype SPV-FHC- 10-VIII-63-1; Pliocene, San Gregorio, Uruguay; Francis and Mones 1965a; Mones 1991, who adds two other specimens), the flexids are anteroposteriorly wider; the p4 has deeper h4i and no h2e; h2i and h3i are shallower, especially the for- mer; and the m3 shows a deep hsi, more anteriorly directed than in C. calingastaense sp. nov., which is reflected in a longer and more triangular first prism. Stratigraphic and geographic range.—Late Miocene, mid- dle section of the Las Flores Formation. Right side of the Candelaria Creek, Puchuzum area, Calingasta Valley, San Juan Province, central-west Argentina.. Phylogenetic analysis We assessed the phylogenetic affinities of C. calingastaense sp. nov. using the dataset and protocols presented in previ- ous studies (Pérez et al. 2018; Madozzo Jaén et al. 2018; see SOM 1–3). The parsimony analysis of the combined dataset (including morphological and molecular partitions) resulted in 333 most parsimonious trees (MPTs) of 3364 steps. The strict consensus of all MPTs is shown in SOM 3. Figure 7 displays the node Hydrochoerinae in the strict consensus. Our phylogenetic analysis recovers the monophyly of Cardiatherium (Fig. 7: node B and SOM 3). At the same time, this clade is the sister group of the largest capyba- ras (a clade including Hydrochoeropsis, Phugatherium, Neochoerus and Hydrochoerus; Fig. 7). Cardiatherium cal- ingastaense sp. nov. is the sister group of the other species A B C D E P4 M1 M2 M3 Fig. 5. Schematic occlusal view of upper teeth of Cardiatherium (A–C) and Phugatherium (D–E). A. Cardiatherium calingastaense sp. nov. (late Miocene, Puchuzum, San Juan Province, Argentina), INGEO-PV 87, right P4–M3. B. Cardiatherium patagonicum (late Miocene, Estancia Rincón Chico, Chu but Province, Argentina), MPEF-PV 740/22, reversed left P4; MPEF-PV 740/23, reversed left M1 or M2; MPEF-PV 740/18, right M3. C. Cardiatherium paranense (late Miocene, Ituzaingó Formation, Entre Ríos Province, Argentina), MLP 87-XI-1-27, right P4–M3. D. Phugatherium novum (middle Pliocene, Chapadamalal Formation, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina), MMP 492-S, right P4–M1. E. Phugatherium cataclisticum (late Miocene–Early Pliocene, Monte Hermoso Formation, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina), MLP 15-231a, right M1. A B C D E p4 m1 m2 m3 Fig. 6. Schematic occlusal view of lower teeth of Cardiatherium. A. Car- diatherium calin gastaense sp. nov. (late Miocene, Puchuzum, San Juan Province, Argentina), holotype, INGEO-PV 87, right p4–m2 and reversed left m3. B. Cardiatherium patagonicum (late Miocene, Estancia Rincón Chico, Chubut Province, Argentina), MPEF-PV 740/9, reversed left p4; MPEF-PV 740/24, right m1–m2; MPEF-PV 740/7, reversed left m3. C. Cardiatherium paranense (late Miocene, Ituzaingó Formation, Entre Ríos Province, Argentina), MLP 40-XI-15-1, right p4–m3. D. Cardia- therium orientalis (late Miocene, Camacho Formation, San Gregorio, Uruguay), SPV-FHC-27-XI-64-20, right p4–m3. E. Cardia therium chasi- coense (late Miocene, Arroyo Chasicó, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina), MMP 300-M, right p4–m2; MMH-CH 88-6-71, reversed left m3. 10 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 64 (X), 2019 Global scale stage/age South American stage/ageE p o c h M a “Ionian” Bonaerian Calabrian Ensena- dan 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Gelasian Piacen- zian Zanclean Messinian Serra- vallian Laventan Mayoan Chasi- coan Tortonian M io c e n e P lio c e n e Chapad- malalan Monte- hermosan Huay- querian Marplatan P ro c a rd io m y s m a rt in o i C a rd io m y s le u fu e n s is C a rd io m y s a m e g h in o ru m X e n o c a rd ia d iv e rs id e n s C a v io d o n m u lt ip lic a tu s C a rd io m y s c a v in u s A llo c a v ia c h a s ic o e n s e C a rd ia th e ri u m c h a s ic o e n s e C a v io d o n c u y a n o C a v io d o n p o z z ii C a v io d o n a n d a lh u a le n s is C a v io d o n a u s tr a lis C a rd ia th e ri u m c a lin g a s ta e n s e s p . n o v. C a rd ia th e ri u m p a ta g o n ic u m C a rd ia th e ri u m p a ra n e n s e C a rd ia th e ri u m o ri e n ta lis a ff . Hydrochoerus Neochoerus H y d ro c h o e ro p s is d a s s e n i ? H y d ro c h o e ro p s is w a y u u C a rd io m y s ? a n d in u s “cardiomyines” largest capybaras Cardiatherium A B C D E Hydrochoerinae 52 52 54 85 93 90 66 P h u g a th e ri u m d ic h ro p la x P h u g a th e ri u m c a ta c lis ti c u m P h u g a th e ri u m s a a v e d ra i P h u g a th e ri u m n o v u m Kerodon P le is to c e n e Fig. 7. Stratigraphic adjustment of the strict consensus tree for the phylogenetic analysis of Hydrochoerinae (333 MPTs of 3364 steps). Upper case letters indicate the nodes within Hydrochoerinae, as described in the main text. Silhouettes reflect external aspect and relative size of representatives of the main clades within Hydrochoerinae. CERDEÑO ET AL.—A NEW MIOCENE CAPYBARA FROM ARGENTINA 11 of the genus (Fig. 7: node B). Cardiatherium and the largest capybaras (Fig. 7: node A) share the following unambiguous synapomorphies: root of the lower incisors extending up to the level of the anterior lobe of m2 (ch. 20); concave palatal surface (ch. 55); presence of h2i on p4 (ch. 86); anterior lo- cation of h3i (ch. 90); hpi deeper than h5i (ch. 96); c3 present on prI of p4 (ch. 98); oblique h3e (ch. 101); posterior prism of m1–m2 complex heart-shaped (ch. 106); presence of hti on m1–m2 (ch. 109); hsi shallower than hpi on m1 (ch. 114); hpi in m1–m2 reaching the labial end (ch. 115); presence of hse on m1–m2 (ch. 116); p4–m1 shorter than m2–m3 (ch. 121); m1